Tuesday, September 27, 2011

The 1920s equivalent of "no-homo."

Today in class we talked about the effect that the change of setting has on the The Sun Also Rises. Our characters are now in Spain, and this has a noticeable effect on Jake and Bill's friendship. At one point, when the two are out fishing, Bill says something that Mr. Mitchell called the 1920s equivalent of the slang term "no-homo" which one "bro" says to another "bro" after they've said something genuinely nice to each other. Bill voices his appreciation of Jake, and says that in New York, that voicing would definitely not be allowed, but here, in Spain, one can say these things.

I think this is a huge forward step in the book, because we already know that Jake and Bill are good friends, and this candid conversation just proves that. However, I was beginning to think that Hemingway would never let two male friends have an emotionally meaningful conversation, and voila! Here's one about Brett! Granted, it's only about five sentences long, but we have to start somewhere right? (In my head, I'm imagining a 12-step program for hyper-masculinity. Bros Anonymous, perhaps.)

I really liked this (almost) conversation because it made me think of Jake as opening up a little bit, and of Bill as not being ironic for a change. It was a nice change of pace, and I hope that Jake and Bill will have more of these moments. Jake's got to spill his guts to somebody at some point, right?

1 comment:

Annie said...

I really like this blog post. Not only is it well-developed and entertaining, but it is also informative about what happened in class today that I missed! Bros Anonymous sounds like a fantastic idea. Moments when Jake opens up are precious because he's such an interesting and complicated character who is so, so quiet. But at the same time, I guess that's also part of the charm of the novel.